NobleBlocks

Research indexJournal article

Study

Pfeiffer

Oncology Times1 Dec 2006

NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260516/9075E254DOI10.1097/01.cot.0000303087.30180.14

Paywalled

The full text is at the publisher

You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.

Read at the publisher

Abstract

Ever since the pivotal trial (NSABP-BO6) that showed identical survival rates among patients undergoing modified radical mastectomy or lumpectomy with radiation, more women have chosen lumpectomy as their primary mode of breast cancer treatment, believing that it spares their breasts and avoids the need for additional reconstructive surgery. But esthetically, this belief is not correct for all women, according to a small study presented at the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) “Plastic Surgery 2006” conference. The researchers found that almost one-third of the breast cancer patients they looked at were dissatisfied with the cosmetic outcome of lumpectomy/radiation and would now consider reconstruction. Traditionally, only patients undergoing total mastectomy are referred for reconstruction, explained co-investigator Howard T. Wang MD, Assistant Professor of Surgery at the University of Texas Health Sciences Center in San Antonio. “But they may not have had access to all the facts in the first place to make the best individual choice of treatment.” For example, “the oncologist may not always advise the patient of possible breast asymmetry and other common cosmetic abnormalities arising from the radiation involved in conserving the breast,” he said in an interview. Another potential disadvantage: the treated breast may shrink and some thickening or other alteration of contour may develop unless the surgeon pays meticulous attention to detail. “To head off unrealistic expectations, the clinician should encourage the patient to consult early with a board-certified plastic surgeon—one with a long track record of successfully working with breast cancer patients—regarding the risks and benefits of reconstruction,” he said. “Patients come to me for help after breast-conservation surgery. Before the operation they had assumed their breast[s] would be saved—but now many tell me they barely recognize what remains as a breast…. My colleagues have reported similar experiences.”Figure: Howard T. Wang, MD: “To head off unrealistic expectations, the clinician should encourage the patient to consult early with a board-certified plastic surgeon—one with a long track record of successfully working with breast cancer patients—regarding the risks and benefits of reconstruction.”Study Specifics The study hypothesizes that a number of patients treated with breast-conservation techniques have suboptimal aesthetic results and should be referred for reconstruction. The study involved 46 patients who had received breast-conservation therapy between the years 1999 and 2004. Their average age was 56.5 years. Using a detailed questionnaire and photography, the researchers found that 28% (13 patients) were dissatisfied with the cosmetic outcome of their treatment. Of these, 46% (five) stated that they considered their physical appearance to be “worse” or “much worse” than before the procedure and were therefore thinking about further reconstruction. Interesting Paradox In an interesting paradox, however, about 10 patients (26%) were so relieved to be free of cancer that even as they stated their disappointment over the way their breasts looked, they said they felt much better about their body image as a whole, Dr. Wang noted. Additionally, approximately 9% of patients who said they were satisfied with the results said they would still consider reconstruction if it were offered. The study could not provide prognostic factors for poor outcome despite a statistical analysis of demographics, the location of tumor, the volume of tissue resected, and the TNM stage, Dr. Wang said. Nor was there always agreement between surgeon and patient as to what constitutes a poor outcome. “Keeping in mind the subjectivity that's involved in a study such as this, it still confirms our hypothesis that as many as one-third of patients are dissatisfied with the cosmetic results of breast-conservation therapy and should be referred for consideration of reconstructive surgery. “In fact, I know of very few studies of partial mastectomy/lumpectomy that report good cosmetic results,” he continued. “The major difficulty is always that one is working with radiated tissue. This increases the risk of capsular contracture as well as significant skin damage with implant reconstruction.”Figure: Walter Erhardt, MD: “As the patient weighs the choice of treatment, there's a tendency to put reconstruction on the back burner. It's a challenge to her doctors to give her the best information as early as possible without causing additional anxiety. That's where having an experienced plastic surgeon on the team comes in. He/she can tell the patient up front that if she chooses breast-conservation her breast may be both conserved and deformed. We can't overemphasize that having a lumpectomy per se does not guarantee a good cosmetic result.”But the technique is controversial, he said. “I personally think the plastic surgeon should remove the radiated tissue and replace it with an autologous tissue flap.” A basic reason for choosing breast-conserving surgery with radiation therapy is to avoid the necessity for expensive reconstruction, Dr. Wang said. “But if nearly 30 percent of women indeed want reconstruction after this procedure—and many more studies must be done to prove this is the case—then it certainly would increase the cost of health care for these women.” Evolving Treatment Asked to comment, Walter Erhardt, MD, a past president of ASPS, who has a private practice in Albany, GA, said he felt that the Texas researchers were “exactly right” in their conclusions. His only caveat was that a woman who had just received a breast cancer diagnosis might be too shaken to carefully analyze the various options suddenly thrust upon her. “As the patient weighs the choice of treatment, there's a tendency to put reconstruction on the back burner,” Dr. Erhardt said. “It's a challenge to her doctors to give her the best information as early as possible without causing additional anxiety. “That's where having an experienced plastic surgeon on the team comes in. He/she can tell the patient up front that if she chooses breast-conservation her breast may be both conserved and deformed. We can't overemphasize that having a lumpectomy per se does not guarantee a good cosmetic result.” It's much harder to reconstruct an irradiated partial breast than to build an entirely new one, he continued. “But we're getting better at it. The treatment is evolving. The breast cancer patient is right to want both a cure and a pleasing aesthetic outcome—and that's our goal, too. Many patients are apparently satisfied with the results of lumpectomy, but they are not the ones who come to us for help.” Last year some 58,000 American women opted for breast reconstruction surgery, according to ASPS data.

Discussion

Topics

More

Suggest a correction or report