Research indexObservational
Study
Henkel
Oncology Times25 Jun 2003
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260515/EB5B8702DOI10.1097/01.cot.0000289823.93585.61
Study
Henkel · Oncology Times · 2003 · Subscription
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260515/EB5B8702DOI10.1097/01.cot.0000289823.93585.61
The full text is at the publisher
You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.
Abstract
SAN DIEGO—In multiple studies, although approximately two thirds of cancer patients with far advanced disease express the desire to die in their own homes, the majority of deaths from cancer occur in hospitals. Following a study conducted at Yale University to plumb this discrepancy, Siew Tzuh (Stephanie) Tang, RN, DNSc, concluded that unless strong family and community resources are available to support such patients and their families, the chance is very slim for the patients to obtain care and die at a place in accord with their wishes. Now an assistant professor of nursing at the National Yang-Ming University's School of Nursing in Taiwan, Dr. Tang presented results of her prospective study here during the 7th National Conference on Cancer Nursing Research. The study is now scheduled for publication in the Journal of Palliative Care. Reasons for Study Dr. Tang's impetus for the study, she said recently from her office in Taiwan, was to address informational shortcomings in the literature. Most studies investigating the factors influencing place of death rely upon death certificates, medical records, or families' responses as sources of information.FigureDr. Tang was interested in soliciting more direct input from the patients themselves. In addition, she said, Despite over two decades of efforts to study the determinants of place of death for terminal cancer patients, there has been no work until now to directly explore the extent of congruence between the preferred and actual place of death for terminally ill cancer patients. “In order to provide end-of-life care in accord with patients' wishes, as proposed by the Institute of Medicine, my study goes beyond the long-standing interests in investigating the determinants of place of death per se to understanding the determinants of congruence between the preferred and actual place of death for these patients.” Study Specifics Accordingly, Dr. Tang recruited 180 study participants from inpatient units of four New Haven, Connecticut-area hospitals. Participants ranged in age from 34 to 88 years. The majority were Caucasian, with diagnoses including tumors of the lung, breast, ovary, and colon. Dr. Tang conducted interviews with study patients lasting about 30 to 40 minutes. She used standard questionnaire measures to assess their symptom distress, functional status, and sense of coherence. Asked 3 Questions The interview schedules for assessing preference for place of death included the following three questions: Some people prefer to die at home, whereas other people prefer to die in the hospital. If everything were possible, where would you prefer to be when you die? [Choices of places to die also included in-patient hospice and nursing homes.] How important is it to you to be in the place that you prefer? How supportive and capable do you believe your family is to help you achieve your preference for place of death? The answers to the last two questions were scored using a 5-point Likert scale. Follow-Up Process After conducting the interviews, Dr. Tang followed each patient's dying process by regularly checking with providers at the study sites, accessing electronic databases such as the Social Security Death Index and online obituaries, and performing chart reviews to obtain detailed information about the care patients received before they died. Patients' place of dying and end-of-life care were then compared with their previous stated preference. The results were also analyzed to discover possible variables to explain the discrepancy between preference and actual place of dying. During the study period from March 1, 2001 to February 28, 2002, approximately 70% of the enrolled patients died. Echoing results from the medical literature, less than a fifth of the patients died at home, despite their overwhelming preference to do so. Analyses of variables leading up to the patients' deaths revealed that readmittance to the hospital emergency room or intensive care unit was associated with the likelihood that those patients would not die in their place of preference. Patients' perceptions of their families' ability to achieve their preference were highly predictive of congruence between the preference and the actual place of death. Over one third of the patients died in an in-patient hospice facility, an interesting finding in light of the fact that the first US in-patient hospice was founded in Connecticut. Dying in an in-patient hospice was not necessarily indicative of a patient's preference (he or she might still have preferred to die at home). Dr. Tang found it surprising that despite the availability of hospice for over two decades in this country—which should facilitate patients' choices and control in decision-making at the end of life—there remains a great discrepancy between what terminal cancer patients want and what they get regarding place of death. “The feasibility of maintaining cancer patients at home and facilitating home deaths is heavily dependent on a prerequisite that family caregivers are available, willing, and capable of supporting patients in the home,” she noted. Other Realms to Explore Her own study was not longitudinal, and took place in one geographic area, two factors which hamper its generalizability to the country at large. One area that warrants further investigation, she said, is the extent of the patient's cognitive and emotional acceptance of his or her approaching death. In addition, it would be enlightening to measure how patients' preferences might change over time in response to worsening physical symptoms, diminished family resources, available health care system factors, or other variables. Additional longitudinal research could increase the understanding of the dynamic decision-making process and the impact of changes on dimensions that affect place of death preferences. “I strongly believe that we as health care professionals should explore preferences for end-of-life care for terminally ill cancer patients,” Dr. Tang said. This may include advance directives about the way they wish to be treated [i.e., no heroic measures] and where they prefer to spend their final days of life. “There is evidence to support the notion that physicians' attitudes toward home hospice care influence their referrals of patients for end-of-life care,” she continued. “If physicians are willing to talk to patients about their preferences for end-of-life care and to respect those preferences, they may be more likely to assess families' resources and ability to carry out patients' wishes. Only then can we find out what difficulties families face and what help they need to help them achieve patients' preferences.”