NobleBlocks

Research indexJournal article

بررسی تطبیقی دیدگاه علامه معرفت و علامه طباطبایی در منبعیت قرآن و روایات برای تفسیر

پور, قمرزاده

SHILAP Revista de lepidopterología21 Mar 2018Open access

NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260515/60278524DOI10.22091/ptt.2018.2832.1302

Abstract

Comparative Study of the Viewpoints of Allameh Ma’refat and Allameh Tabatabaii on Making Reference to the Quran and Narratives for Exegesis Abdolkarim Behjatpoor [1] Mohsen Ghamarzadeh [2] (Received: 18/06/2017; Accepted: 06/09/2017) Abstract One of the important issues raised in exegetic methods is the “sources of exegesis”. These sources either originate from Wahy (revelation) and its redefinition or are extracted from the rational and experimental efforts of humans during centuries. The differences in exegetic methods are related to the commentators’ choice of source. By scrutinizing the viewpoints of Allameh Ma’refat about the exegetic sources of a work, this research paper attempts to find out the distinctions between his and Allameh Tabatabaii’s views in this regard. As the primary source of exegesis, Allemeh Ma’refat is more concerned about narratives and other exegetic books while Allameh Tabatabaii focuses on the Quran. In order to answer the research question, a comparative analysis has been made between the views of Allameh Ma’refat and Allameh Tabatabaii on the Quran and divine and historical narratives including the narrative from Prophet Mohammad and Ahl al-Bayt. By analysis of arguments regarding the validity of each of the above sources, their commonalities, and also advantages, it becomes evident that the disagreement between these two commentators is related to the intermingled state of instrumental and referencing sciences in exegesis, difference in the definitions of exegesis, and also lack of differentiation between the terms exegesis and elucidation of the Quran.

Discussion

Topics

More

Suggest a correction or report