Research indexJournal article
Презумпція правомірності рішень платника податків у практиці адміністративних судів
Смичок
1 Jan 2020Open access
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260515/83A62718DOI10.32837/pyuv.v0i3(32).603
Презумпція правомірності рішень платника податків у практиці адміністративних судів
Смичок · 2020
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260515/83A62718DOI10.32837/pyuv.v0i3(32).603
Abstract
The article is devoted to a detailed analysis of the legal nature of presumption of legality of taxpayer's decisions one of the initial provisions of tax legislation, the substantive aspects of which developed within the case law. Thus, the author focused on the specific features of the presumption of legality of taxpayer's decisions. Relevant features are established based on research including the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission). As a research task, the author paid attention and determined the specifics of the relationship of the judicial doctrine of presumption of legality of taxpayer's decisions with other judicial doctrines, namely: the doctrine of business purpose, the doctrine of good faith of the taxpayer, etc. A distinction is make between the judicial doctrines of the presumption of legality of taxpayer decisions from the doctrine of good faith of the taxpayer. It is note that the presumption of legality of decisions is designed to ensure legal certainty in tax law enforcement precisely in cases, where the law provides for an ambiguous interpretation of the rights and obligations of participants in tax relations. The article analyzes the current case law in which the main conceptual requirements of this presumptive provision of tax legislation are be formed. It is be established that the courts consider the presumption of legality of taxpayer decisions as a special rule, which establishes a requirement which law enforcement entities must interpret all regulatory doubts in favor of the taxpayer. It is emphasize that the presumption of legality of decisions is in inseparable unity with the requirements of the principle of legal certainty. The principle of legal certainty itself is an element of the principle of the rule of law. It is this starting point that ensures the predictability of law enforcement practice. In turn, the principle-presumption of legality of the taxpayer's decision is a specific tool (technical and legal technique) that allows ensuring the realization interests of the taxpayer in case of actual uncertainty of law enforcement algorithms.