NobleBlocks

Research indexBook chapter

Rational Frames?

Bermúdez

Cambridge University Press eBooks15 Oct 2020

NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260525/4F4DA984DOI10.1017/9781108131827.005

Paywalled

The full text is at the publisher

You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.

Read at the publisher

Abstract

This is where we are after the first four chapters. On the one hand, it looks as though we fall prey to framing effects everywhere we turn, from supermarket shelves to our retirement accounts. On the other hand, accepted theories of how to make rational choices all hold that being susceptible to how outcomes are framed is a paradigm of irrationality. The psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman make this dilemma very vivid. They offer us two theories – expected utility theory and prospect theory. One (expected utility theory) is a normative theory – a theory of how rational agents are supposed to make decisions and navigate practical problems. The second (prospect theory) is a descriptive theory – a theory that has built into it much, if not all, of the irrationality condemned by the normative theory. And there is no chance, they clearly state, of bringing the two theories into harmony. The reality, they think, is that practical reasoning is irremediably irrational. And so, we have fuel for what I earlier called the litany of irrationality.

Discussion

Topics

More

Suggest a correction or report