NobleBlocks

Research indexObservational

北大生におけるメンター

若井

Hokkaido University Collection of Scholarly and Academic Papers (Hokkaido University)1 Jan 1997Open access

NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260525/02D5DAA6DOI10.14943/j.highedu.2.163

Abstract

In line with the call for paradigmatic shifts in other sciences, there are some conspicuous trends for constructing new perspectives in psychology.Particularly stressed there are relational, ecological, dynamic, and longitudinal approaches.In the past, psychology has put too much emphasis on individuals, almost neglecting the fact that the individuals' behaviors and mental processes are embedded in various environmental conditions.Needless to say, individual persons can never live in a vacuum, and are always interacting other people and environments.Especially concerned here is what and how young people in contemporary Japan are enjoying or suffering from human relationships.Guided by Vygotsky's idea that the activities and the associates who share the activities are the two locomotives of one's psychological development, we launched a Japan-US comparative study on experiential contexts of cognitive development some fifteen years ago.This is an interim report of the author's recent research deriving from the collaborative study.In order to probe the social network of students at Hokkaido University, two questionnaires surveys were administered.One asked the subjects about significant others for them, and the other asked the subjects to rate 55 items on seven-point scales, judging how each of the items fits as a characteristic of a 'mentor.'In addition, interviews were conducted with some other students to get a more realistic picture of significant others or mentors as a kind of case study.Majors findings obtained through the two questionnaires were as follows; (1) Female subjects more frequently named same-sex (female) associates than male subjects.(2) Percentages of 'friends', 'teachers' and 'parents' mentioned as 'significant others' were much higher than other categories of associates.(3) Reasons for 'significant others' varied among the subjects, but 'specific teaching', 'being a model or a goal', 'full of charm as a person' (category No. 5), and 'a person who makes other people feel close' were most common.Male subjects more often referred to No. 5 and 'shared hobbies and experiences'.Female subjects, on the hand, more frequently mentioned 'peer relations and companionship' and 'close friends or lovers'.(4) Analysis of the rating of the characteristics of a 'mentor' showed that the most important characteristic was 'having firm beliefs and something to engage in', and 'attitudes toward others' placed second, 'techniques of teaching' third, 'sociability' fourth, 'Professional ability' fifth, and so forth.Although only six students were available for interviews, each case offered a very interesting picture of the relationship between the subject and the 'significant other' for a contemporary university student.In this brief interim report, two cases are introduced and commented on; one is an example of a 'mentor' who is a divorced mother but has been working very hard and is respected by the female subject, and the other is quite the opposite in that the male student interviewed named his own father as a significant other because the father had been a kind of antagonist for the subject but profoundly influential for him and eventually the subject is taking the same course in life, as a doctor, as his father.

Discussion

Topics

More

Suggest a correction or report