Research indexJournal article
Διαγνωστικά Κριτήρια και Ψυχιατρική Ηθική
Gounaris
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)1 Jan 2008Open access
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260525/32CD4EB8DOI10.5281/zenodo.17872583
Διαγνωστικά Κριτήρια και Ψυχιατρική Ηθική
Gounaris · Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) · 2008
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260525/32CD4EB8DOI10.5281/zenodo.17872583
Free to read at the publisher
You can read the abstract here, or the full text at the publisher.
Abstract
Abstract: If someone browse the Diagnostic and Statistical Manuals of Mental Disorders (DSM) over the years will conclude that our tolerance to what we are considering healthy is eventually decreasing. This discussion is about behavior related mental disorders that we evaluate as undesirable and therefore unhealthy. Two important areas that can be criticized on the validity of the diagnostic manuals, and the ethical responsibilities that are connected on them are: [A] disputes and major problems related to social, cultural or religious beliefs and different ethical principles adopted by different societies. [B] the problem of language but mainly an important conceptual confusion between "Criteria" and "Symptoms". Wittgenstein pointed out and emphasized the difference between criteria and symptoms. In most cases, the only criteria of mental disorders diagnosis are the symptoms themselves. This creates a serious issue for the reliability of the criteria compared to other fields of medical science. In general, medical diagnoses, are based in key criteria to determine for example an existence of a virus, or a malformation, a fracture, a stroke, an anemia, etc. But in the case of so-called "mental disorders, the criteria of diagnosis are only the symptoms, that means the symptomatic behavior. As human beings we use to construct and explain concepts, disorders, illnesses and normality, because we believe in what we observe and in what we consider as average. Then, we think that the constructed terms or, in this case, the disorders are existing in reality. We believe in the reality of concepts because, as Nietzsche says, we believe in logic. The concept of mental health (ie the evaluation of what is healthy and what is not), has maintains a "real" world of 'psy' professions and “professionals”, pharmaceutical industries, clinics, laws, institutions, patients, etc. Questioning about diagnostic criteria and also about the very concept of mental disorder, raises a series of ethical issues related to the non-consensual hospitalization, the involuntary commitment, the forced treatment or the right to deny treatment, the dilemma of choosing therapist, the psychiatric confidentiality, the legal attribution of responsibility issue, etc.