NobleBlocks

Research indexBook chapter

Introduction

Richter

25 Aug 2026

DOI10.1093/9780197847176.003.0001

Paywalled

The full text is at the publisher

You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.

Read at the publisher

Abstract

Associate Professor of Classics and History In 1854, George Fitzhugh of Port Royal, Virginia, observed that the history of western civilization is a story of two thousand years of steady decline from the unparalleled genius of classical Athens to the mechanized malaise of industrialized modernity. Even the ancient Romans, Fitzhugh lamented, Imitated and fell short of Greece, in all the departments of moral philosophy, in pure metaphysics, in poetry, in architecture, in sculpture, in oratory, in the drama and painting, and we today imitate Rome. It is idle to talk of progress, when we look two thousand years back for models of perfection … The ancients understood the art, practice, and science of government better than we.1 Fitzhugh articulated a fairly typical antebellum southern attitude toward the classical Greek and Roman past: while the Athenians of the classical age offer models to emulate, the decadence of late Rome provides exempla to avoid. On the Greek side, for many intellectuals of the antebellum South, it was the political theory of Aristotle that best exemplified the Greek genius. As a contributor to the Richmond Enquirer in October 1855 put it, “Aristotle’s ‘Politics and Economics’ should be made a text book in every college of the Union.” It was a sentiment echoed by scores of southern intellectuals in the decades prior to the civil war.2 The period of Roman history that most interested the antebellum intelligentsia was the late republic and early empire, an epoch that they understood as marked by the corruption of almost every human virtue. As John Tyler Jr. (writing under the pseudonym “Python”) declared of late republican Rome in 1857, “lust and crime, hand in hand, stalked the land … civil commotions quickly arose, to be speedily succeeded by general civil war.”3 This book takes up two questions related to the use of the classical past, specifically in the context of the proslavery argument as it developed in the 1830s, 1840s, and 1850s. First, what specific ideological needs did Aristotelian ideas about natural hierarchy serve in the antebellum South? This is a question of some interest, since ideas about natural slavery explicitly marked as Aristotelian had been universally rejected by slavery’s apologists almost from the moment of their formulation in the fourth century BCE. Why were antebellum southerners, virtually alone in the history of the reception of Aristotle, the first to generally approve of the Aristotelian idea that some ethnic groups are naturally suited for slavery? My second question is why did the generation of Americans that came of age in the first half of the nineteenth century focus almost exclusively on the evils of Rome of the late Republic and early empire, while the founders had looked to early republican Rome as a model for the new nation?4 The answers to both questions, unsurprisingly, have much to do with race and slavery. But this is only part of the problem and, as we shall see, perhaps not the most interesting part. In this book, I argue that there is much more at work here than southerners simply looking to the past for precedent and justification for their own racialized and gendered hierarchies. I hope to explain how, on the subjects of race, slavery, and politics, many antebellum southern intellectuals saw the classical past less as a model and more as a foil. In parts one and two of this book, I argue that from the southern point of view, the slave systems of both Athens and Rome were radically incomplete, conceptually, legally, and practically. While Aristotle may have correctly theorized the existence of a slave race, the Athenians failed to identify it. The Romans, for their part, were the architects of a slave system that was fatally compromised both by the “heathen” cruelty of the institution and, more importantly, by the fact that the slave system of the Romans was unnatural insofar as they held in servitude ethnic groups who were of the same “blood” as themselves. By contrast, southerners argued an enlightened Christian paternalism animated the slave system of the antebellum South, and that they held in bondage human beings whose innate natures did, in fact, conform to the ideal type of the Aristotelian natural slave.

Discussion

More

Suggest a correction or report