Research indexMeta-analysis
Осевое время: современные дискуссии
Matveychev
Voprosy filosofii25 Aug 2026
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20261105/57BA7356DOI10.21146/0042-8744-2026-8-65-74
Осевое время: современные дискуссии
Matveychev · Voprosy filosofii · 2026 · Subscription
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20261105/57BA7356DOI10.21146/0042-8744-2026-8-65-74
The full text is at the publisher
You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.
Abstract
The concept of axial time, developed by Karl Jaspers in the late 1940s, generated a lot of discussions among representatives of historical sociology, religious studies and philosophy of culture, which continue to this day. The article is a meta-analysis of a large amount of data on the “axial time”. The first group of arguments concerns the problems related to the periodization and the real validity of the synchronicity of the appearance of axial doctrines and religions in different places of Eurasia. Various critics of Jaspers’ concept point out that the spiritual movements of China, India, Greece, and Palestine do not have a clear common denominator – each developed for its own reasons and at its own pace. Many of the processes, described by Jaspers, began earlier or lasted noticeably longer than the so-called axial epoch; there was also no instantaneous gap between the epochs, rather, they are united by a succession relationship. A number of authors insist that the axial epoch, accentuated by Jaspers, was not the only one in history. The universality of Jaspers’ theory and its applicability to all cultures are also being questioned. In the era of specialization and microhistory, the concept of axial time is a rare example of a comprehensive idea that connects antiquity with modernity and provides a platform for interdisciplinary dialogue. The data from these sciences tellingly confirms the theory of A. Weber, with whom Jaspers entered into a controversy.