Research indexJournal article
[研究論文(原著論文)] 美的経験の最小説 : その問題点と修正方針
藤本
Contemporary and Applied Philosophy24 Aug 2026Open access
[研究論文(原著論文)] 美的経験の最小説 : その問題点と修正方針
藤本 · Contemporary and Applied Philosophy · 2026
Abstract
Robert Stecker attempts to approach the concept of aesthetic value using the explanatory term "aesthetic experience."For this position (experientialism) to hold, it is necessary to properly define the aesthetic experience.In this paper, I critically examine Stecker's definition of aesthetic experience, namely the minimal view.The minimal view is used as a foundation for further discussion in aesthetics, but as this paper points out, it has several problems.First, contrary to Stecker's expectations, the requirement of discrimination-that "in aesthetic experience, one must attend to the object's properties in a discriminating manner"-is insufficient to adequately distinguish aesthetic pleasure from non-aesthetic pleasure (Section 3.1).Second, the "attention for its own sake" requirement-namely, that "in aesthetic experience, one must attend to the object's properties for their own sake or for the sake of this very experience"-can be interpreted in multiple ways (due to its obscurity); however, regardless of which interpretation is adopted, the minimal view cannot adequately specify the extension of aesthetic experience (Section 3.2).This paper also proposes a modification of the minimal view to resolve these issues.This modification involves expanding the concept of form while eliminating "quality" and "meaning (meaningful features)" from the objects of attention in aesthetic experience (Section 4.1).Furthermore, this paper fleshes out the requirement of discrimination by providing two paradigmatic examples of "attending in a discriminating manner".One of these has been largely overlooked in previous research (Section 4.2).