NobleBlocks

Research indexBook

الحديث، سلطته ونقده في سياق قضايا النوع الاجتماعي: النقاش الأول

Abd-Elsalam, Amin

perspectivia.net1 Jan 2026Open access

NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20261105/2F933CC5DOI10.25360/01-2026-00033

Free to read at the publisher

You can read the abstract here, or the full text at the publisher.

Read at the publisher

Abstract

Ḥadīth has been called by traditionists as "the backbone" of the Islamic civilization. Its importance lies in that it is the second source of fiqh (jurisprudence) after the Qur'an, but also that it permeates all Islamic literature, be it tafsīr (exegesis), Prophetic biographies and/or other genres. It ranks second to the Qur'an, yet sometimes it even gets elevated above the Qur'an. Medieval Muslim scholars already acknowledged that much of the Ḥadīth corpus was fabricated and devised methods to sift the authentic from the forged, like ʿilm al-rijāl (science of narrators), al-jarḥ wa-l-taʿdīl (criticism and praise) and others. Until the 4th/10th century Muslim scholars applied their criticism on both parts of the Ḥadīth report, namely the isnād (chain of narrators) and the matn (text body), yet after that they only focused on the isnād. Muslim scholars from the 2nd/8th century until today have never stopped repeating that "The isnād is part of the religion — if it was not for the isnād, whoever wanted could say whatever they wanted and ascribe it to the Prophet." Muslim feminists criticized Ḥadīth reports in general and women-unfriendly reports in particular, finding faults with particular narrators, using the biographical dictionaries while applying the same criteria used by the Muslim scholars, yet they are also not acknowledged. Many western methods, which resemble the medieval Muslim scholars' methods are also not acknowledged, like the common-link being the madār for example and other methods, like the isnād-cum-matn (ICM) analysis. Newer "western" methods, some by Muslim scholars, using digital humanities to analyse the matn in terms of growth to the text, additions and deletions, placing the reports and narratives in their contexts, as well as analysing the terms found in the biographical dictionaries regarding the probity of the narrators, also remain unacknowledged by clerics. This book puts the different scholarly approaches in a nuanced academic dialogue to introduce the different methods to one another, aiming to arrive at mutually acceptable methods to enrich the study of Ḥadīth and attempt to clear some of the superfluous additions to the prophetic Sunna. Questions the book deals with are: Can the Ḥadīth prove to be a reliable source for historical gender inquiry into the 1st/7th century, despite its codification in the 3rd/9th century? Can genres of Ḥadīth convey insights that contradict or confirm the tafsīr tradition? How might different methodological approaches to the Ḥadīth and new analytical techniques shed new light on the Ḥadīth corpus? How does Ḥadīth affect key historical Islamic scholarly disciplines that have shaped classical legal texts? What ethical dimensions in the application of Islamic legal principles are informed by the Ḥadīth especially in gender issue? Are there any effects of the interdisciplinary engagement with other genres such as tafsīr, ṭabaqāt, akhbār, al-jarḥ wa-l-taʿdīl and as are important!bāb al-nuzūl. Judeo-Christian elements, such as the isrāʾīliyyāt, impacted the Ḥadīth and other Islamic literature, yet their effects and possible counter-measures. What are ethical justifications for the use of known forged and fabricated Ḥadīth or not, especially considering the Qur'anic text?

Discussion

More

Suggest a correction or report