NobleBlocks

Research indexThesis

การยกเลกโทษจำคกตลอดชวตในกฎหมายอาญาไทย

เมธาสถิตย์สุข

1 Jan 2025

DOI10.58837/chula.is.2025.364

Paywalled

The full text is at the publisher

You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.

Read at the publisher

Abstract

This individual study aims to examine the situation of final-sentenced prisoners serving life imprisonment in Thailand after their convictions become final. It analyzes relevant concepts and theories of criminal punishment and related criminological perspectives, compares the laws governing life imprisonment in the Thai criminal justice system with those of foreign jurisdictions, and proposes guidelines for amending the law to replace life imprisonment with a determinate sentence featuring a prescribed maximum term. The study finds that life imprisonment under the Thai criminal law system constitutes an indeterminate sentence, as its actual duration depends on unpredictable factors such as the offender’s age at sentencing and their life expectancy, which cannot be known with certainty even by the court. Consequently, this results in unequal periods of life imprisonment among individuals at the time of sentencing. Furthermore, life imprisonment fails to achieve the comprehensive objectives of punishment. It creates internal contradictions within the legal principles for prescribing criminal offences and penalties, unnecessarily seeks to permanently protect society from the offender's potential danger, and constitutes a disproportionate sanction. In contrast, a long-term determinate sentence can satisfy the principles of the objectives of punishment, reflecting both the gravity of the offence and the offender's blameworthiness. Because judicial proceedings provide the stage where the court can most clearly evaluate each individual offender, it is appropriate to apply a statutory maximum penalty alongside a statutory minimum term, while leaving the determination of the exact number of years to be served to judicial discretion. Therefore, this study proposes the abolition of life imprisonment to ensure legitimacy and proportionality in sentencing, thereby aligning Thai criminal law with modern criminal justice principles as well as fundamental human rights standards.

Discussion

More

Suggest a correction or report