Research indexJournal article
Developing a Network Analysis Method for Studying Collaborative Physics Learning in Digitally Intensive Classrooms
Turkkila
University of Oslo1 Mar 2026Open access
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260516/23B86324DOI10.5617/nordina.12850
Developing a Network Analysis Method for Studying Collaborative Physics Learning in Digitally Intensive Classrooms
Turkkila · University of Oslo · 2026
NobleIDark:/48914/w1/20260516/23B86324DOI10.5617/nordina.12850
Abstract
This dissertation presented the development of a novel network analysis method for studying collaborative learning in authentic, digitally intensive science classrooms. The background is the idea that new technologies, societal changes, and advances in pedagogical theory lead to new teaching practices and new forms of learning. For research to continue informing teaching, these new practices must be studied, and new methodological developments are required. The need for this development come from the aim of investigating how students learn disciplinary knowledge in authentic, digitally intensive settings. An authentic setting refers to science classrooms during curriculum-based activities, while digitally intensive settings involve the use of digital tools such as computers and scientific instruments. Materiality-based approaches are essential to account for these tools and understand how knowledge is produced in such environments. In this method, materiality is approached through actor-network theory. The development of the method was demonstrated through three studies in two physics education contexts. The first study examined online discussions in pre-service physics teacher education. These discussions enabled straightforward network data collection and the testing of functional network roles as an analysis method, which proved suitable for studying small-group collaboration. The second context involved upper secondary school physics lessons. Study II explored methods for generating network data from video recordings of students’ investigations using a materialist framework. Three approaches were identified in the literature: 1) information flow, 2) material semantic, and 3) material engagement. These were then applied to a video segment from a digitally intensive upper secondary physics lesson, demonstrating that network analysis can effectively study the material and dialogic relationships that emerge during student investigations. In the final study, the information flow networks from the previous study were quantitatively analysed using functional network roles. In addition, an approximation of node deletion was applied to assess actor importance, complementing the role analysis. The results revealed interaction patterns and quantified the importance and roles of the actors. Together, the three studies allowed for the development of the method and demonstrated its applicability for future research. The method enables comprehensive investigation of complex interactions during small-group collaboration and how students learn disciplinary knowledge in authentic, digitally intensive settings.