NobleBlocks

Research indexBook chapter

Introduction

Marcus

Between Thought and Expression24 Nov 2026

DOI10.1093/9780197871102.003.0009

Paywalled

The full text is at the publisher

You can read the abstract here, or open it at the publisher.

Read at the publisher

Abstract

The Introduction lays out the book’s guiding distinction between sense—what speakers do in making themselves intelligible—and meaning, the truth-conditional content of what they say. A statement can lack sense without lacking meaning, as Moore’s Paradox (“p, but I don't believe that p”) shows; variants recurring across belief, action, desire, exhortation, aesthetic judgment, and validity form the book’s central diagnostic. Two theses, pursued in every chapter, are introduced: that an attitude is constituted in part by our special way of knowing we hold it (Shoemaker) and that the standards to which it is answerable partly constitute what it is (Hieronymi). These converge in the thinker’s capacity to avow her attitudes, whose exercise just is an application of the relevant standard. Against Gricean, inferentialist pictures of uptake, understanding what someone says is not an inference to her state of mind but a grasp of the sense she makes.

Discussion

Citations

More

Suggest a correction or report