Research indexJournal article
Правова природа та межі допустимого застосування аудіо-, відеоконтролю особи як засобу кримінального процесуального доказування
Старенький
Law and Safety12 Oct 2026Open access
Правова природа та межі допустимого застосування аудіо-, відеоконтролю особи як засобу кримінального процесуального доказування
Старенький · Law and Safety · 2026
Abstract
This article examines the legal nature of audio and video surveillance of individuals and defines the limits of its permissible use as a means of evidence in criminal proceedings. The relevance of this study stems from the lack of established judicial precedent regarding the distinction between lawful audio and video surveillance of individuals and covert methods of obtaining testimony, which creates a risk of violating criminal procedural safeguards and the use of inadmissible evidence. The purpose of this article is to examine the problematic issues of distinguishing audio and video surveillance of individuals from covert interrogation, to develop scientifically grounded criteria for their differentiation, and to determine their significance for verifying and assessing the admissibility of using the results of the relevant covert investigative (search) actions in criminal procedural evidence. The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the provisions of Ukraine’s criminal procedural legislation, doctrinal approaches, and current Supreme Court practice regarding the application of Article 260 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine. The author argues that the decisive factor in determining the legal nature of audio and video surveillance of a person is not the formal procedural designation of the action conducted, the location where it took place, or the method of documenting the results, but rather the mechanism for generating evidentiary information, the nature of communicative interaction among the participants, and the role of the prosecution in its occurrence. It is demonstrated that audio and video surveillance of a person loses its inherent functional purpose if the entity conducting the relevant covert investigative (search) action purposefully organizes and directs the process of obtaining information by determining the subject of communication, asking questions, or otherwise actively influencing the communication. Under such conditions, the activity in question effectively takes on the characteristics of a covert interrogation. This paper proposes an informational-functional criterion for distinguishing audio and video surveillance of a person from covert interrogation and clarifies its significance for verifying and evaluating the results of the relevant covert investigative (search) action from the perspective of admissibility. It is argued that the results of audio and video surveillance obtained through de facto covert interrogation must be evaluated through the lens of Articles 86 and 87 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, since their inadmissibility stems from a violation of the legally established procedure for obtaining evidence and fundamental criminal procedural guarantees, in particular the right to defense and the right not to incriminate oneself.